Weathered brownstone townhouse entrance with a dark oak door, tall bay windows and worn bluestone steps.

Sam's Is Back on Court Street. Here's What the New Owner Kept, and What She Changed

For years, Sam's closed every August. Lou Migliaccio spent the month in Italy, and anyone who wanted the pizza or a veal parm waited until he got back after Labor Day. This year the restaurant at 238 Court Street stayed dark through August again, but for a different reason. Georgia Fulton, the new owner, had planned to reopen in midsummer. A film crew moved into the space, and the reopening slid to September 10, Grub Street reported.

Two months later, the dining room is close to the room people remember. Fulton's team rebuilt the food carefully, almost dish for dish. Nearly everything new is at the bar, in the booking system and in the posted hours. A longtime regular will recognize the menu. Getting a table works differently now.

The new owner started as a regular

Sam's has been on Court Street between Baltic and Kane since 1930. Brothers Danny and Sam D'Arco founded it, and Danny named it for Sam. For nearly all of the 96 years since, the people serving you were the Migliaccio family. Brooklyn Magazine notes that Lou spent his entire life at Sam's before deciding this year to hand it to Fulton.

Fulton came to Sam's as a customer. She first walked into Sam's in 2021, kept coming back, and spent 12 years working nearby at Long Island Bar. "I truly just stepped in the door about five years ago and immediately fell in love with the place," she told Brooklyn Magazine. "So I committed myself to coming once a week for all those years, to develop a relationship with Lou and with the space."

She worked alongside Lou for six months before Sam's closed in 2025, according to Grub Street's earlier profile. Patch's account adds that she spent those months working weekends there, learning the operation before he gave her the keys. Her years as a customer explain the reopening. The goal was to bring back the Sam's she ate at.

The recipes were rebuilt from Lou's coffee cups

Bringing the food back was harder than it sounds, because there wasn't much written down. The chef consultant is Andrew Halitski, who previously ran La Rose, a Detroit-style pizza spot in Cobble Hill. He told Grub Street that Migliaccio's recipes, when they existed at all, were written in a private shorthand.

"There was no recipe book. Lou showed me the special coffee cups and dishes he'd use to do the measurements."

The pizza oven has no thermostat and runs on two gas pipes. "These ovens just need to be babied a little bit," Halitski told the outlet. That oven still turns out the pizza that has anchored the menu for decades. The other holdovers include the olives-and-celery appetizer, baked clams, and the parms with spaghetti or ziti on the side.

The new dishes were designed to blend in. Orecchiette with broccoli rabe and sausage, a Caesar salad, rigatoni alla vodka and a pork chop Milanese are all on the menu. "We've finessed it so it's pretty close to the original," Fulton told Grub Street. The printed menus are by May Redding, who has worked on her sister Ann's restaurants, including Thai Diner. She built them from old menus and archival material going back almost to the opening.

The tableware stayed the same too. Lou's green-trimmed plates are still in use, and salads still come in wooden bowls with metal tongs. The sign out front is the same one. In the dining room, the main changes are bar stools, a bench near the entrance for people waiting, and a partition between the bar and the dining area.

The bar changed the most

If the kitchen's job was to bring the food back, the bar's job was to change. Sam's always had a long cocktail list, but according to Grub Street it was mostly for show. Now Rene Hidalgo, who runs the bar, treats it as a real drinks program. "This is red-sauce, Italian American. It's not an Italian restaurant," he told Grub Street. "How far away from this thing can we get where it still continues to be this thing?"

The list mixes classics with new drinks:

  • Classics: a Cuba Libre, a Singapore Sling, and a Rob Roy made with both Cutty Sark and Laphroaig
  • New: a house spritz with rhubarb amaro, and a Spaghett Shakerato, which is shaken Aperol topped with Miller High Life
  • Prices on the restaurant's online menu: $14 for the Spaghett Shakerato, $18 for a Martini, Manhattan, Rob Roy or Rusty Nail

Sam's also keeps bar hours that run past the kitchen. The last dinner seating is at 10, and the bar stays open until 11. A neighbor who used to come only for dinner can now stop in for a late drink.

What dinner costs now

Brooklyn Magazine's review, published September 21, 2026, lists prices that give a good picture of a full meal. The pies are old-fashioned, eight-slice and brick-oven. The reviewer called them "the perfect pizza for this place." A cheese pie is $27 on the restaurant's online menu, and most toppings add $3 to $5. The half-pepperoni pie the reviewer ordered came to $30.

The parm platters are the big plates. The online menu has eggplant parm at $28 and chicken parm at $30. Brooklyn Magazine called the chicken version, which comes with spaghetti, "a bargain at $30" after seeing how much cutlet arrived. A $30 parm costs about the same as a pie with toppings, so splitting one of each feeds a table without a big jump in the bill.

The rest of the reviewer's order, as listed in that review:

  1. Mozzarella sticks, $13
  2. Orecchiette and sausage, $24
  3. Sam's Special Salad, $19
  4. Sam's Sundae, $14, with pistachio, chocolate and strawberry gelato under crushed almond cookies

The same review puts beers at $8 and full glasses of wine at around $15. Eater has since added Sam's to its October Brooklyn new-restaurants heatmap, noting that the room still feels familiar and praising the food.

Getting a table works through OpenTable now

This is the biggest practical change for anyone who just used to show up. The posted hours are:

  • Wednesday through Saturday: 5 p.m. to 10 p.m. last seating
  • Sunday: 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. last seating
  • Bar: until 11 p.m.

Reservations go through OpenTable, which books up to 14 days ahead and holds some tables for walk-ins. The new bench by the door was added for people waiting. OpenTable lists American Express, Mastercard and Visa as accepted payment. Gift certificates are sold through the restaurant's website.

Next door at 240 Court Street

The block got another new arrival this fall. Compton's Sandwich Shop is open at 240 Court Street in the former Moo Burger space, according to the October 17 issue of The Gowanaut. The first Compton's opened in Queens in 2018, and the Court Street shop is its Brooklyn location. The Cobble Hill Collective newsletter describes it as a lunch option with a retro-inspired room and vintage Pac-Man arcade games.

That gives this stretch of Court Street between Baltic and Kane a sandwich counter open for lunch and a 96-year-old red-sauce room serving dinner from Wednesday through Sunday. Sam's still runs its pizza oven by feel and serves on Lou Migliaccio's green-trimmed plates, and dinner tables now come through OpenTable.

When a storefront like 238 or 240 Court changes hands, the block changes with it. If you own or rent nearby and want to talk about what that means for your building, Michael Torsiello follows these blocks closely and is happy to talk it through. Contact Michael.

Let’s Make Your Next Move Count

Every move deserves a strategy built around you. Connect with Michael for personalized guidance and a smarter approach to New York City real estate.

Follow Me on Instagram